Tag Archives: sotheby’s

Article VIII: The Lawyers: Lying, False Claims, Threats and Insanity: Social Ventures in Africa? by Brian Ray Dinning, JD, LLM and social venture lawyer

Article VIII:  The Lawyers:  Lying, False Claims, Threats and Insanity

 

By:  Brian Ray Dinning, JD, LLM and Social Venture Lawyer[1]

 

July 20, 2012

 

What does a lawyer who was suspended from practicing law for three years for making false claims against me and others and not being truthful with a court and other unprofessional and tortious behavior with a history of insanity have to do with this story? A LOT!  He is one of the lawyers for the bad press collaborators (see Articles III through VII at www.socialentrepreneurshipinafrica.com).   Jason Christopher Roper and his close friend and former law partner, George Bowles are the lawyers for the aggressive bad press campaign collaborators.  These two lawyers not only participated in most, if not all, of the aggressive bad press campaign, they are the two people who have profited substantially by representing this group – earning hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees.

 

George Bowles was the lawyer for Batte and Stiner.  Bowles contacted business associates of Pure Africa, Earth Conservancy and me in an effort to damage and discredit the social venture projects in South Africa and me and to support his claims.  On at least two occasions, Bowles contacted our business partners (general contractors and builders from Virginia who were overseeing the development work on the Wild Coast of South Africa) to discredit me and to engage in a fishing expedition to solicit them as clients in a possible legal action against me.  Interfering with and damaging existing business relationships, providing false and inflammatory information and then seeking to represent these people is wrong – it is illegal and actionable (tortious interference) but it is also against a lawyer’s code of ethics.

 

These actions by Bowles are not only unprofessional and unethical but they cost the projects hundreds of thousands of dollars in lost investment and the loss of two or more business relationships.  Our business relationships with general contractors a year or more to develop since the projects are in Africa and generally included one or more due diligence trips to South Africa.  Each time one of these relationships was destroyed by Bowles, it cost the social venture projects in time, money and valuable resources.  Bowles and his clients also sent confidential and privileged information to Bossie Bosman, which was used to discredit us in South Africa with the government, our professional team, our local community partners and our business partners.[2]  He also admittedly shared confidential and privileged information with his good friend and former partner Roper.  It is unclear whether Bowles’ law firm, Williams Mullen is aware of the tortious, interfering and damaging conduct.[3]

 

Jason Christopher Roper was actively involved in the aggressive negative press campaign in an illegal and actionable way as well.  He openly advertised for new clients on the blog of Jeff Brown and he admitted to contacting the South African government and others in an effort to damage and discredit the projects and me.  He also admitted to working in concert with and sharing confidential and protected information with his good friend, Bowles.  Together, these two worked hard to damage and discredit the projects and me and they profited handsomely from their efforts through the payment of legal fees by Batte, Stiner and the other bad press campaign collaborators.[4]

 

The contact by Roper and Bowles to the government of South Africa, to Sotheby’s International Realty, to Pam Golding Properties and others stopped our projects on at least three specific instances directly:  at Mdumbi Bay with Fresh Properties,[5] at Hole in the Wall with Sotheby’s International Realty,[6] and with Pam Golding Properties.[7]  Each time this occurred, it stopped the marketing campaign and cost the social venture projects millions of dollars in revenue.  This revenue would have been used to repay our financial partners and to provide for a financial return to the local community and the social venture partners.  It is unclear how many indirect opportunities were lost to the bad press campaign but I know of several instances where business relationships ended due to the blog of Jeff Brown and others.

 

Many times, we tried to stop them from interfering by sending letters of support and seeking endorsements from all of our professional team members.[8]  We also sought and received endorsement letters and support from the Government of South Africa including South African President Jacob Zuma, National Cabinet Members and National and local government.[9]

 

Roper and Bowles coordinated the legal attack on me and the social venture projects to line their pockets with legal fees.  Instead of simply asking the social venture projects for a return of their money, they sued first using a generic fraud complaint.  Since the only way to get to an individual personally instead of the business is by alleging fraud, they started off by using a general allegation of fraud to file a lawsuit against me personally as well as against the social venture companies.  In the first three cases, the social venture partners and myself settled three lawsuits by paying back the investors in full with interest and attorneys’ fees.  The next legal battle was with the Stiners.  The social venture companies would have eventually paid them back as well when funding was available to settle the lawsuit but the damage that they did to the social venture projects through the aggressive bad press campaign plus the death threats against me led us to agree that settling the lawsuit was not appropriate and a countersuit was filed.  It was then that the Stiners dismissed their lawsuit forever.  The final lawsuit (other than the $30 million lawsuit pending against the bad press campaign club filed by me) was a lawsuit filed by Roper.  This suit cost Jason Christopher Roper his job because my legal counsel and I were present when the senior partners of his firm at McKenry Dancigars said to him that “there is no case.”  Roper continued with the lawsuit contrary to his firm’s advice and was fired.  Strangely, he then reportedly attempted to commit suicide, was hospitalized and then continued to practice law until his recent suspension.[10]

 

I was finally able to achieve a small victory with Roper through the Virginia State Bar.  Judge Karen Burrell documented Roper’s negative, unprofessional and attacking behavior against me in both correspondence and court order.[11]  On February 17, 2012, Jason Christopher Roper was suspended from practicing law for three years by the Virginia State Bar.  The announcement from the Virginia State Bar reads:

 

     “Jason Christopher Roper, 702 Lakeview Court, Mars, PA 16046

VSB Docket Nos. 09-021-080040, 10-021-080199, 10-021-080602

On February 17, 2012, the Virginia State Bar Disciplinary Board suspended Jason Christopher Roper’s license to practice law for three years for violating rules governing candor toward the tribunal; fairness to opposing party or counsel; respect for rights of third persons; confidentiality of information; conflict of interest: general rule; conflict of interest: former client; declining or terminating representation; meritorious claims and contentions; ; communication with persons represented by counsel; bar admission and disciplinary matters; and misconduct.”

 

This, in turn, gave me the necessary evidence to prepare and file the current $30 million lawsuit including claims for federal civil RICO against Jason Christopher Roper, George Bowles and the bad press campaign collaborators.  My goal with the lawsuit is to fight for the rights of the social venture partners, the investors and donors, the local poor communities in Africa and me against this negative and actionable conduct by a small group of people. These people cost us millions of dollars in potential profit, millions of dollars of costs and expenses and years of hard work and effort for the people of Africa.

 

Just to highlight the attacking, unprofessional and unbalanced thinking of this group, Roper sent this scary and threatening email to me:

 

“Mr. Dinning:

Good morning and congratulations on your indictment!  May you enjoy the next twenty to thirty years in a nice federal peneteniary without the comforts of your bimbo wife, your kids, or the finer things in life . . . Don’t worry about your wife.  If she appears at your trial, I will make sure to inform her that if she needs a good serving, she can always give me a call. 

 

Laughing still.

Jason C. Roper”

 

My legal counsel responded with:

“Mr. Roper –

I was just forwarded your communication with Mr. Dinning.  Note that your communication itself, as well as the content, are not only violative of PA ethical rules, but are unlawful in and of themselves.  Besides being disgusting and offensive. 

Given your history of unstable and violent behavior, I must take your statements, especially as to threatened sexual assault on Mrs. Dinning, as real threats to her well being and report the same as well as insist that you never, in any manner, communicate with my client again.  If you do so, appropriate legal action will be taken in Pennsylvania. 

I’m not saying this to argue with you, and I will not respond to any response or argument that you make in return.  You either comply or don’t.  If you don’t, I will take appropriate action.”

After sending this to my lawyer, misconduct bar complaints were filed by my legal counsel and me in both Virginia and Pennsylvania for this shocking and threatening behavior.

This is not the conduct of rational people.  What I have shared with you is the actual, documented conduct of some of our financial partners and their legal counsel in social ventures in Africa.  It is also the conduct of the principle instigators behind the current charges pending against me in the United States as a final blow in their aggressive bad press campaign.

 

While I am happy to face them in court, I wanted to tell my side of the story and to share with you my heart for the people of Africa.  While no one is perfect, all of my consulting fees, expenses, personal expenses and draw compensation was documented in consulting agreements and authorized by the social venture companies.  You do not have to take my word for it though, as I have attached a letter from one of our social venture partners, Dr. William Brown, Ph.D Professor and Fulbright Scholar to Assistant US Attorney Steve Haynie in February, 2012.  In this letter, Dr. Brown (which can be supported and corroborated by “dozens of people” according to Dr. Brown) openly discusses the aggressive bad press campaign and the fact that my consulting fees and expenses were all authorized and approved by the Board of Directors and by my consulting agreements.[12]

 

While I am happy to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth in court, I can tell you that my reputation, family and over 16 years of work on social ventures has been irreparably damaged by this unjust process.  The truly sad thing is that the real impact of this will be against the local people in Africa, who were and are counting on us for help not to mention the wildlife that is counting on us for safety and protection.[13]  I can only hope that others will take up the cause of social ventures in Africa (despite the risks I have described) and help the local people of Africa to help preserve and conserve their land and natural resources for future generations to enjoy.

 

 


[1] My background is at http://www.avvo.com/attorneys/23321-va-brian-dinning-629141.html

[2] George Bowles, for his part in the aggressive bad press campaign, is listed as one of the defendants in the pending $30 million lawsuit by me and Pure Africa to reclaim some of the damage caused by their reckless and intentional actions in damaging me and the social venture projects.  Our goal is to ensure that the projects move forward for the benefit of the local communities in Africa.

 [4] Jason Christopher Roper has already been suspended for three years from practicing law for his unprofessional and attacking conduct against me by the Virginia State Bar as documented by Judge Karen Burrell in both correspondence and court order.  Jason Roper, for his part in the aggressive bad press campaign, is listed as one of the defendants in the pending $30 million lawsuit by me and Pure Africa to reclaim some of the damage caused by their reckless and intentional actions in damaging me and the social venture projects.  For his background, see http://www.avvo.com/attorneys/15219-pa-jason-roper-537025/reviews.html

[6] Sotheby’s emails.

[10] It should also be noted that Jason Christopher Roper was fired from his last two law firms (Blumling & Gusky and McKenry Dancigars) and it is reported to me by other attorneys that he was fired from two previous law firms for similarly bizarre and unprofessional behavior.

[11] See Letter from Judge Karen Burrell.  Article 8 FN Judge Burrell Letter re Roper

[12] See Letter of Dr. William Brown to Steve Haynie, Asst. US Attorney  Article 1 FN 1 Letter from William Brown to Mr. Haynie

[13] Letter from Xolile at Mdumbi Bay Community Trust.  Article 8 FN Xolile 2012 Letter

Advertisements

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Article VI: What’s at Stake with the Social Ventures in Africa: The Community’s Heritage and Prized Treasures by Brian Ray Dinning, social venture lawyer


Article 6:  What’s at Stake with the Social Ventures in Africa:

 The Community’s Heritage and Prized Treasures

 By:  Brian Ray Dinning, JD, LLM and Social Venture Lawyer

 

July 13, 2012

You may be asking – what are these social venture projects?  What is it like at Hole in the Wall?  Why would people like Granville Batte, Jeff Brown (White South African hotel owner at Hole in the Wall and slanderous blogger) and Allan Stiner want to steal projects from the community, our social venture partners and me?  How about $98,818,000 of the most sought-after beautiful, untouched oceanfront land on the Indian Ocean in South Africa?  This is the value of the raw, undeveloped land held by the social venture between the community and Pure Africa as determined by a South African property expert and a real estate developer.[1]  To those trying to steal our social venture projects, this is like hitting the lottery – to the local community, it is their future and a means to lift their entire communities out of poverty.  My vision is to stop the cycle of Apartheid and the exploitation of the local community at the hands of people like Batte, Stiner and Brown, to a social venture structure where the community owns 25% to 45% of every project.  The local impoverished community should and must benefit substantially from the sustainable development of their land – it is their right and heritage.

In order for you to fully understand the above statements, I will share a bit of our project vision for the local people in Africa with you and why the community land is so special. The local Xhosa people live on less than $1.00 per day, on average.  They are very poor in a worldly sense but they are blessed with tremendous natural resources – their oceanfront land.  The average tribal leader has less than a sixth grade education, so while they have amazing land – they do not have the tools, skills or education to know how to maximize the value of the land.  This is where our social venture partners bring in the education, know-how, a professional team of lawyers and real estate companies and the finances to help the local community sustainably develop a real estate project to create jobs, job skills training and hopefully profits.  Don’t get me wrong – social venture projects are for-profit – so our goal was to maximize the value of the community land so that the community, our social venture partners and financial partners can all benefit.

Hole in the Wall is a cultural[2] and National icon in South Africa (see photo below).  It is a large rock mountain in the Indian Ocean that boasts beautiful scenery and ocean views.  In 2004, the Development Bank of South Africa “DBSA” and the South African Government funded a study on creating a tourism project at Hole in the Wall.[3]  Our social venture project company was called Incopho, headed up by Bossie Bosman.  In 2004, DBSA, the government and Incopho created a project summary for several projects including:  Hole in the Wall and the Golf Course at Coffee Bay.[4]  In 2005, our social venture partners received a Lease from the South African National Government to develop the community project at Hole in the Wall[5] and a Record of Decision (building permit and authorization) was issued in late 2005.[6]

Views of Hole in the Wall from Development Site

Now, it is well-known that nothing happens in Africa without a meeting:  we literally had hundreds of hours of meetings with the local chiefs, the tribal counsel, the community trust and the local people to show them the business plan and the proposed benefits to the local community.  In Africa, everyone has a right to speak so the meetings were attended by hundreds of people – both young and old.  Once everyone had a chance to voice their opinions and concerns, then we would finalize our social venture project plan.  Finally, after our projects were approved by the local community, we then sought approvals from the National, Provincial and local government.  Once everyone was happy with and had approved the business plan at a social venture like Hole in the Wall, then we would begin.  This initial process takes from 18 months to several years for each project!

At Hole in the Wall, after three years of meetings, the approved plan was to build a tourism site with 50 oceanfront rental homes and a boutique hotel[7] which would create a minimum of 57 jobs for the local community and the potential for hundreds of micro business jobs such as beadwork, tours, sea shell jewelry and other tourism souvenirs and hopefully profits from the development (the community owned 45% of the Hole in the Wall development as our partner).

Architect’s Rendering of Proposed Lodging at Hole in the Wall

In order to help fund the social venture project, Earth Conservancy and The Pure Africa Sustainable Development Fund provided initial funding of $563,000 to pay for engineering fees, architects, plans and approvals and initial project consulting and development costs.  However, funding for construction costs and utilities installation was still needed.  The Development Bank of South Africa expressed initial interest in providing funding to Incopho as early as 2006.[8]  The Development Bank of South Africa then told me that they submitted the social venture project at Hole in the Wall for approval for funding of R25,000,000 or $4,000,000 to put in utilities and facilities.[9]  One of the conditions of DBSA funding is matching funds from the social venture partners so we needed financial partners to assist in funding the project at Hole in the Wall.

Our professional team provided great endorsements of the projects.  We agreed to approach Sotheby’s International Realty to market the Hole in the Wall project.[10]  On May 6, 2008, Lofty Nel, a Principal with the firm of Sotheby’s International Realty provided a letter to the project, which reads:

“Lew Geffen Sotheby’s International Realty are extremely proud and honoured to be granted the exclusive mandate to market Pure Africa Development LLC Hole in the Wall project on the Wild Coast in South Africa.  Marketing of the project has commenced by word of mouth with the official launch of the project scheduled for the end of May, 2008.

The development comprises 51 Ocean front homes in a gated estate at the Hole in the Wall, a national landmark in South Africa.  Earth Conservancy have also been appointed to manage approximately 5000 acres of pristine land adjacent to the project as part of a conservancy.  This will ensure that the amazing views and natural beauty of Hole in the Wall will remain intact for guests and owners at the Hole in the Wall development.”[11]

The 50 lots plus a hotel site were priced for long term lease at an average price of $120,000 per lot for total projected revenue to the social venture project of $6 million.[12]   The engineering firm prepared a lot layout for the Hole in the Wall and architects, engineers, and home builders were appointed to get the project ready to market.[13]

In addition to community and government approval, we also sought the approval of specialized real estate legal counsel.  On September 1, 2008, Russell Linde, South African real estate attorney of the law firm of Smith Tabata provided Pure Africa with a legal opinion letter:

“We act on behalf of the aforesaid Pure Africa, LLC as majority shareholder of Incopho Wild Coast Development Projects (Pty) Ltd.  Incopho, in turn, is the majority shareholder of the project company, The Reserve at Hole in the Wall (Pty) Ltd.  Our firm has represented The Reserve at Hole in the Wall project on behalf of Pure Africa since 2007 as legal counsel.  We also assisted in the referral of the project auditor, Charteris &  Barnes, auditors.

Based upon a review of the documentation, The Reserve at Hole in the Wall is an oceanfront and oceanview real estate development consisting of 50 stands and a small hotel.  The Reserve at Hole in the Wall is being marketed by Lofty Nel of Sotheby’s International Realty in East London, South Africa.

The original documentation for this project dates back to September, 2004.  For this letter, I have reviewed the following:

The Final Scoping Report dated September, 2004;

The Review of Documents relating to proposed Coffee Bay and Hole in the Wall developments by East Cape Development Corporation and the Development Bank of South  Africa;

The Ground Lease by and between the Kwa Tshezi Community and Earth Conservancy dated February 6, 2006;

The Lease Agreement between The Government of the Republic of South Africa through the Department of Land Affairs, the Kwa Tshezi Community and Incopho dated February 2, 2006;

The Record of Decision from the Department of Affairs, Environment and Tourism dated August 10, 2005 authorizing Incopho “to construct 50 single storey chalets, a central restaurant, a curio shop and amenities and association infrastructure at Hole in the Wall, KSD Municipal Area.

The Lease Agreement between The Government of the Republic of South Africa through the Department of Land Affairs, the Kwa Tshezi Community and Incopho dated June 21, 2008 which is a 30 year renewable lease at the option of Incopho for up to 90 years and continuing thereafter.

It is also my understanding that Title Deed to the land comprising the Hole in the Wall development is forthcoming to the Community in the next 6 months or longer from the Government of South Africa and the Department of Land Affairs.

Based upon a review of this documentation, Incopho has a valid lease with the Government of South Africa and the Kwa Tshezi Community for up to 90 years or more.  Under South African law, Incopho through The Reserve at Hole in the Wall (Pty) Ltd. can sublease the 50 stands to interested sublessees for rental payments over the term of the lease or the rent and lease may be prepaid.  It is my understanding that sublessees can “purchase” or sublease one or more of the 50 stands for an up-front payment of rent or with 10% downpayment of rent and the balance of the rent payments over 10 years at 12% interest.

It is my understanding that Sotheby’s International Realty will be acting as estate agent in the “sale” of the 50 subleased stands to the general public.  A separate company,  Villager Homes, will be constructing homes on the 50 subleased stands under separate written agreement between Villager Homes and the stand “purchasers” or sublessees.

Finally, when Title Deed is ultimately vested with the Kwa Tshezi Community, it is planned that the 50 stand sublessees may have the opportunity to convert their lease to Title Deed ownership of their stand.”[14]

By May, 2008, all architectural designs, engineering, lot layout, utilities and infrastructure plans were completed and a contract to install all utilities, roads and services to The Reserve at Hole in the Wall were completed.  These crucial steps made it possible for marketing of long term leases for the 50 lots by Sotheby’s International Realty.

In May, 2008, Sotheby’s began to issue marketing materials for Hole in the Wall[15] and in September, 2008, Hole in the Wall was listed as a “hot property” in Conde Nast Home in South Africa and Media Press Releases were issued.[16]  Sotheby’s also went to great expense to create glossy brochures to begin marketing and they also launched a marketing website for the Hole in the Wall project.[17]  Pure Africa and the social venture partners put up a marketing Sign Board at the Hole in the Wall project.[18]  Everyone was excited because Sotheby’s and their marketing experts were certain that the property would lease quickly and that meant up to $6 million of projected revenue for the social venture project and the local community.

However, just as the marketing campaign was beginning, the aggressive bad press campaign team of Batte, Stiner and others jumped in to actively interfere with and destroy the marketing efforts at the Hole in the Wall project.  This was the most damaging tortious interference that resulted from the aggressive bad press campaign – anonymous phone calls from this coordinated group to our real estate professional team and social venture partners.[19] At the launch of the Hole in the Wall project and at other projects, Sotheby’s International Realty, government officials and others received several anonymous phone calls from Virginia and from South Africa stating that the projects were false, that we were trying to sell (versus lease) community land and that I was not someone to be trusted.  The callers also threatened to and did take the matter to the newspapers to discredit Sotheby’s and the social venture projects.  In discussions with Sotheby’s and other real estate firms, we were told that a new development, especially a social venture development, is a delicate matter and you only want positive information for the general public to view when seeking to spend money on a new oceanfront resort.  The decision was made to halt the marketing campaign at Hole in the Wall and try to regroup later.  This was devastating to us because it meant that years of time, effort, money and relationships were wasted.

Each time a project was halted by the malicious and negative actions of Batte and his coordinated bad press campaign, we had to stop everything and try to work on a new project that hadn’t yet been attacked by this group.  However, each time the task grew harder and everyone on the social venture team was tired of the negative attacks and the disappointment and damage that resulted from the negative attacks.

While the social venture projects on the Wild Coast in partnership with the Xhosa community have great potential, many people want to take them over for their own personal gain. Why does it seem to be so difficult to help the poor in Africa?  I know that Oprah Winfrey had a very hard time starting up her social venture project in Africa[20] and the Washington Post and others have reported on the United Nations aid workers sexual abuse of children[21] and also on billions in stolen aid money[22] and corrupt practices by US companies.[23]  In fact, this must be commonplace because I was on the phone with two other social venture project managers in Africa who have had similar experiences to mine.

The next Article describes how Batte, Stiner and others started coordinating with people in Africa in an organized “Wonga-style” coup attempt to either take the social venture projects for themselves or destroy them and me.  The next Article is entitled:  On the Ground in South Africa:  Not Much Better –  Social Ventures in Africa.


[1] See Wild Coast Property Valuation at Article 6 FN 1.  This valuation was prepared by real estate expert Alan Bell and real estate developer David Stefano based upon comparable property values on existing real estate for sale on the Wild Coast of South Africa.

[2] Known in Xhosa tradition as the place of The Great Cattle Killing, Hole in the Wall is steeped in cultural fokelore and significance for the Xhosa people.  For a short version of the legend, see http://www.southafrica-travel.net/eastcape/wildcoast.htm

[3] DBSA Scoping Report is attached hereto as Article 6 FN 3.

 [4] See DBSA – Incopho Project Overview as Article 6 FN 4.

 [5] See National Government Lease to Incopho as Article 6 FN 5.

 [6] See Record of Decision to Incopho as Article 6 FN 6.

[7] See Hole in the Wall Aerial Lot Layout and Site Plan at Article 6 FN 7.

[8] See Development Bank of South Africa letter to Incopho at Article 6 FN 8.

[9] See Development Bank of South Africa email to me at Article 6 FN 9

 [10] See Pure Africa letter to Sotheby’s at Article 6 FN 10.

 [11] See Letter from Lofty Nel of Sotheby’s International Realty at Article 6 FN 11.

 [12] See Plot and Plan Pricing at Article 6 FN 12.

[13] See Model Home specifications by Villager Homes at Article 6 FN 13.

[14] See Opinion Letter of Smith Tabata Law Firm at Article 6 FN 14.

[15] Sotheby’s Booklet showing Hole in the Wall Development at Article 6 FN 15.

 [16] See Conde Nast Home article naming Hole in the Wall a “Hot Property” at Article 6 FN 16.

 [17] See Sotheby’s website layout at Article 6 FN 17.

 [18] See Pure Africa Hole in the Wall signboard at Article 6 FN 18.

[19] See Letter from Dr. Brown to South Africa Department of Land Affairs at Article 6 FN 19.

[20] For an overview of the sexual abuse and other scandals at Oprah’s social venture projects, see http://www.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1939460_1939452_1939416,00.html

FOOTNOTE ATTACHMENTS:

Article 6 FN 1 Land Valuation

Article 6 FN 3 DBSA HITW Scoping Report

Article 6 FN 4 DBSA Overview of Projects

Article 6 FN 5 South African National Government Lease for HITW

Article 6 FN 6 Record of Decision

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Article 6 FN 8 Development Bank of South Africa initial letter

Article 6 FN 9  Development Bank  of South Africa R25 Million email

Article 6 FN 10 Pure Africa letter to Sotheby’s

Article 6 FN 11 Sotheby’s Endorsement Letter copy

Article 6 FN 13 Villager Home design for Hole in the Wall

Article 6 FN 14 Pure Africa (Opinion Letter for Hole in the Wall

Article 6 FN 15 Hole in the Wall Listing in Sotheby’s

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Article 6 FN 19 William Brown Letter to Land Affairs Mtata Ltr Oct08 re false information from Bosman Stiner

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Introduction to my Social Venture Work in Africa by Brian Ray Dinning, JD, LLM and Social Venture Lawyer

Article 1: Introduction to my Social Venture Work in Africa

By: Brian Ray Dinning, JD, LLM and Social Venture Lawyer

June 27, 2012

NOTE: As I am writing this series, I have been wrongly accused of wire fraud related to social venture projects in Africa and face a trial in the United States. See Footnote 1.  While I do not believe I have done anything criminal, that decision is likely in the hands of a jury of my peers and I hope and pray that truth and justice will ultimately prevail. The purpose of this series is to tell my side of the story, complete with letters, video, emails, documents and all backed up by witnesses. As a lifelong follower of Christ, I trust in God and his promises like John 8:32 “Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.” (NIV) I also want my wife, children and family to know that I did my very best to help as many of the 400 million poverty-stricken people of Africa as I could and I will work as long and as hard as I can to help them for the rest of my life.

I also want my family, friends and others to know the truth behind the delays, slowdowns, obstacles and impossible situations we faced when doing social ventures in Africa. While it has been disheartening at times and sometimes I just want to give up, I often think of men like Nelson Mandela, who endured years in prison only to be released to become the President of South Africa. As Mr. Mandela states:

“Let there be justice for all. Let there be peace for all. Let there be work, bread, water and salt for all. Let each know that for each the body, the mind and the soul have been freed to fulfill themselves.”        NELSON MANDELA, speech, May 10, 1994

“The greatest glory in living lies not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall.” NELSON MANDELA, Autobiography

My aunt and uncle were Christian missionaries in Africa and my family performed missions work in South Africa for over 35 years. Brought up in a dynamic faith-based household, I was always taught that we must care for orphans, widows and the poor – and that everyone is born with a purpose in life. As unlikely as it might sound, by the age of 10, I knew I wanted to be a lawyer, and I also knew that one of my purposes in life was to help people in Africa. It wasn’t until much later in life that I understood how I might combine those two ambitions.

I’ve been a practicing lawyer for 22 years and, up until recently, I’ve had a spotless record, full of accomplishments and commendations that have brought me and my family a great deal of pride. As a tax and business consultant to energy and mining companies in 2011/2012, I was able to charge an hourly rate for consulting work of $400 and I am blessed to make a good living in the for-profit world. In social ventures, you can also make a salary or work as a consultant but sometimes (most times) the pay is not as good.

I have had the privilege of traveling to Africa over 60 times, and in 1992 through 1994, I helped my professor at Georgetown University write a legal textbook on how nonprofit organizations can do for-profit social ventures, which is the foundation of the modern day social venture or social entrepreneurship project. This work resulted in the legal treatise entitled, “Sanders, Partnerships and Joint Ventures Involving Tax Exempt Organizations” (Wiley & Sons 1994).

I started doing work for clients in Africa in 1994 and have been working on social venture projects in Africa ever since then. These were missions-type projects where we would help build a church or community center, help with clean water, renewable energy, organic food and more. In this work, I realized that the local people of Africa had dreams to become something more, to be connected to the world that existed beyond the boundaries they were confronted by – to also ensure that their children had a future. So, I believe that I was blessed with the talents, ability and vision to look for innovative ways to help the local people in Africa to create jobs, income and a future. This was – plainly stated – to look at their natural resources (land, water, wildlife, mineral rights etc.) and help them locate the tools (people, financial partners and education) to help them maximize those resources – by building a tourism lodge, starting a micro business or starting a minerals project. This way, the local African people could achieve sustainability – meaning they could feed their families, afford to send their children to school and have food and clean water. More importantly, when talking with local community elders, they overwhelmingly said they want to provide a bright future for their children.

Initially, in 1994, I was asked to go to South Africa with some filmmakers to do a reconciliation film entitled “The Final Solution” by filmmaker Christopher Krusen about the life of a dynamic lawyer turned missionary named Gerrit Wolfaardt. This changed my life because Gerrit told me that “you must meet the heartfelt needs of the African people in order to talk to them about God, and missions work and micro enterprise. A starving person needs to be fed first before all else.” On this trip, I met John Coors, the youngest of the Coors brewery brothers. John hired me as a consultant to help with his project “Golden Photon” – which was designed to create solar energy water pumping systems to provide clean water to the rural communities in Africa. They also created a solar energy battery charging system to charge car batteries, which could be used, exchanged and reused by local people to power a light, radio or other electric appliance for their homes. Both were designed as micro businesses and were ingenious social ventures. These men, Gerrit Wolfaardt and John Coors, were pioneers in social ventures and I am thankful for the example they set for me. With my recent research and writing on how non-profits can do for-profit ventures, I was perfectly suited to help them.

These were amazing times because the Apartheid Era had just ended a few months earlier and Nelson Mandela, jailed 27 years by the Apartheid Era as a terrorist, was now the President of South Africa at the age of 76! The entire country was buzzing with life and hope – and expectations: for example, Nelson Mandela promised that he would help provide housing for all people so tens of thousands of people living in the rural countryside moved into the cities expecting to be given a home – not understanding that such a promise would take decades to complete. I met Bishop Frank Retief of the St. Johns Church of England in Cape Town, where eleven people were tragically killed in a church bombing by those loyal to Nelson Mandela in their struggle for freedom. Such stories of loss and tragedy and yet miraculously the Government of South Africa switched control from all White to mostly all Black in a short span of months – and all without any bloodshed. South Africa was a new nation and I was blessed to travel there several times a year from 1994 to the present.

In 1998, I met a man in Stellenbosch, South Africa, the wine country outside of Cape Town, who had heard of our social venture work and asked if I would like to travel to a country in need, Central African Republic, and work at a National Park, Manova Gounda St. Floris National Park – a World Heritage Site in Danger. From 1980 to 1999, the once rich elephant population dropped from 66,000 to 2,000 – all victims of poaching! It is also one of the poorest countries in all of Africa and its population is being ravaged by HIV/AIDS. After researching the country and the issues, I agreed to travel with him to Central African Republic in 1999.

Knowing that we needed a lot of help, I called Ted Turner’s office at CNN in Atlanta. His assistant listened to my story and then told me to send a fax to her office. Three days later, I received a call from Ted Turner’s office asking me to go to his newly formed UN Foundation in Washington, DC to meet with them. In 1999 – 2002, I worked as a consultant for Earth Conservancy where we partnered with UNESCO and the UN Foundation in Central African Republic to manage three large National Parks including Manova Gounda St. Floris National Park. In 2001, Earth Conservancy organized a UNESCO and United Nations sponsored mission trip to assess the current state of the National Parks. Headed by an intelligent and insightful woman named Elizabeth Wangari from UNESCO’s World Heritage Center, the trip and mission in May, 2001 was a great success and we had amazing adventures including several Presidential receptions with President Ange Felix Patasse.

We built two small tourism camps to help create jobs and to teach the local community about conserving wildlife so that tourists would come to the untouched paradise. There were many stories about life and death struggles with poachers, being held at machine gun point by soldiers, the amazing biodiversity and wildlife, walking on foot into a pride of lions, cannibals, naked pygmies and more. As early as 2000, we heard of the terrible persecution of Christians in Southern Sudan. In fact, it was the Sudanese soldiers who were the primary poachers in the National Park. With all this land, millions of acres, I thought the National Parks would be a perfect place to also provide sanctuary for those people being persecuted in Southern Sudan – just across the border from Manova Gounda St. Floris National Park.

Based upon these visits, in 2000 and 2001, prior to September 11, 2001, I wrote several White Papers to the late Congressman Murtha asking the US Government to help in our Central African Republic work as the small country is surrounded by Libya, Sudan, Chad and Congo. In meeting with the Congressman, I suggested that a peacekeeping and conservation mission would allow the US Government to post intelligence personnel so that these dangerous areas filled with terrorist training camps could be watched. The White Papers were bounced around the US Congress and different government agencies and I met with many people but it was decided that since the US Government did not have a formal presence in Central African Republic that our Government could not help. Tragically, we learned that many of Saddam Hussein’s terrorists trained just across the border from Manova Gounda St. Floris National Park. I often wonder if these terrorists could have been detected or stopped earlier had we been able to establish an intelligence gathering post in Central African Republic, while also doing our humanitarian and wildlife conservation work.

But, as life always evolves and circumstances change, one week after our United Nations sponsored trip to Central African Republic, the military of the country staged a coup, President Patasse fled the country taking untold millions of dollars with him and most of the government officials we worked with were killed. With the help of his friend Qaddafi (who I met in 2000 along with President Nicephore Soglo of Benin) and the Libyan and Congolese army, Patasse regained control of the country but a successful coup ousted him from power in 2003. Ten years later, after a failed Presidential bid to become the President of Central African Republic again, former President Patasse died in Cameroon in February, 2011.

The sad story is that the people of Central African Republic, who live in a country filled with the most amazing natural resources, remain the poorest of the poor in Africa. Also, the infamous warlord Joseph Kony and his rebel army are thought to be hiding out in those beautiful National Parks in Central African Republic still abducting children, raping, murdering and promoting terror. Tragically, due to circumstances beyond our control, the work for the local poor in Central African Republic remains unfulfilled. I often dream of that beautiful country and the people there and in Southern Sudan and wish I could have done more to help.

In 2002, my law firm was sponsoring The Shakespeare Theatre season of productions in Washington, DC. I was asked to represent the firm at a gala banquet for the Shakespeare Theatre in Washington, DC. There I dined with Justice Ruth Bader Ginsberg, Justice Rehnquist and the newly-appointed Head of Africa at USAID, Constance Newman, now Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs. Ms. Newman was fascinated by the social venture model of partnering for-profit and non-profit companies to promote community-based projects in Africa. Ms. Newman asked that I meet with her staff at USAID and provide power point presentations and keep her updated with any progress.

At the same time, in 2003 and 2004, Dr. William Brown, a Fulbright Scholar and Ph.D Professor, and an innovative film crew worked with Earth Conservancy to produce two award winning HIV/AIDS education films work in Kenya and Tanzania with the United States Department of Defense. The films focused on the true life stories of soccer stars and promoting education, testing and awareness of HIV/AIDS. Winning awards at the Houston WorldFest film festival, the films achieved the goal of educating young people about HIV/AIDS and were shown throughout Kenya and Tanzania using a screen projector shown on bedsheets sewn together by a team who traveled from village to village. Earth Conservancy stills works in Tanzania and I am working on the establishment of social ventures with Dr. Steven Kiruswa, Ph.D and Maasai warrior, at his home town near Mount Kilimanjaro.

In 2005, our social venture team was privileged to partner with several local Xhosa Tribal communities in South Africa to help them manage and sustainably develop tens of thousands of acres of beautiful oceanfront property.  See Footnote 2.  Sotheby’s International Realty said it is the most untouched and beautiful coastal property remaining in South Africa.  See Footnote 3.  Because all of the small beach hotels were run by local white South Africans under a for-profit model – meaning they did not share any profits or ownership with the local people – our goal was to help the local community develop their own natural resources where the local people were actually partners in the projects.  See Footnote 4.  This would allow the local communities to not only receive jobs and education but also potentially receive profit, if the projects succeeded. Through Earth Conservancy, we also participated in three missions trips to build a church and a playground for a local orphanage. We also sent hundreds of bicycles, tons of food and clothing, soccer balls, medical supplies, computers and school supplies to the local people from clothing and bicycle drives that my wife and I organized.

As of today, I am still working as hard as I can for social ventures to help the poor in Africa. In 2011 and 2012, I helped to pay the start up costs for several new social venture projects in organic farming, education and a wildlife refuge and I have not received any compensation for my efforts. Furthermore, I started to pay back my past compensation from the social ventures to be discussed in this series. My goal is to help the people in Africa and to do my best – along with other caring people – to create sustainable and successful social ventures in Africa.

Article 2 in the Series is entitled: Social Ventures in Africa: What can go Wrong?

FOOTNOTES 1-4

Article 1 FN 1 Letter from William Brown to Mr. Haynie

Article 1 FN 2 Sotheby’s Endorsement Letter

Article 1 FN 3 Hole in the Wall Listing in Sotheby’s

Article 1 FN 4 Legal Opinion Letter for Hole in the Wall by Smith Tabata Law Firm

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized